Pepe Nero Ristorante & Pizza

So there you have it — lots of buzz for this pie. And I’ve read the restaurant is a favorite of Prague’s Italian community. But you know me, ever the contrarian. I had to see about this myself.

Pepe Nero’s interior is light and bright, with blonde floors, blonde chairs, and semi-nude brunettes on the walls.

Very Italian. We started off with drinks. The Englishman had a half-liter of Pilsner Urquell (70 CZK). Jersey Girl had a .2 liter glass of Italian merlot (80 CZK). She said it was smooth and slightly sweet.

I stuck with a bottle of Mattoni mineral water (40 CZK).

Jersey Girl had a small, mixed salad (50 CZK).

She dressed it herself with balsamic vinegar and olive oil that was on the table.

The Englishman said he thought the best test of a restaurant’s pizza-making ability is to order the classic Pizza Margherita, so that’s what he got (165 CZK).

Jersey Girl got the Bufalina (240 CZK). It’s essentially the same as the Margherita, but with mozzarella di bufala instead of cheese made from cow’s milk.

The mozzarella di bufala had a better, clearer flavor, but I’m not sure it was worth an extra 75 CZK.

Of course, I had to sample a few other things on the menu, so I ordered one of my favorite dishes, risotto alla pescatora (270 CZK).

The high-quality Carnaroli rice was perfectly al dente and studded with fresh pieces of calamari, clams, and mussels. Parsley was cooked up in the mix. Overall, the flavor was very good.

But there were also a couple of problems. First, one or two of the mussels were a little less than fresh, with a strong fishy flavor. Second, one of the clam shells had shattered during cooking. It wasn’t visually obvious, but after a couple of bites, I was picking out shell shards from my mouth. Not pleasant.

That dish also contained shrimp and occasionally langoustine and benefited greatly from fresh-torn parsley, rather than cooked. But I haven’t eaten there in a long time. Unfortunately, they became inconsistent in their preparation. On a good day, though, it was the best.

I wondered how they handled meat, so I ordered the grilled entrecote (390 CZK).

The meat had a light, almost veal-like color, and it sat almost alone on the plate with just some tomato slices and lettuce. Even at this price point, side items were extra.

When I ordered, the waitress asked if I wanted it cooked to medium. I told her I’d like it medium-rare. Instead, it came out medium, or even a bit past that point.

That was a shame because it was a high-quality, very tender cut of meat.

I was also disappointed with the seasoning. It was cooked in olive oil, which was nice, but the beef was bland and under salted. I added salt myself, but it took me a few attempts to get the level right, and it would have been so much better if it was properly seasoned just before cooking.

I felt this steak had great potential, but it didn’t live up to it because of inattentive preparation.

I thought I should sample a dessert and didn’t feel like something as heavy as tiramisu, so I had the panna cotta (90 CZK).

I was disappointed. The texture was very rubbery. The sweet, condensed milk was just too simple, and the chocolate lightly drizzled on top added almost nothing to the flavor.

Jersey Girl had an espresso (50 CZK).

I had a latte macchiato (60 CZK). Both of us found the coffee to be very bitter.

Let’s come full circle, so to speak, and consider the main question here: does Pepe Nero have the best pizza in Prague?

First of all, “the best” is such a subjective term, and I don’t like to use it. I prefer to talk in terms of “favorite,” which is less imposing.

That simple pie was a revelation, with each humble ingredient singing like Pavarotti.

Da Michele’s pizza did have a thinner crust, and there was much more of a char on it. It had a very smoky flavor. The sauce tasted more of basil. The San Marzano tomatoes distilled the very essence of the fruit.

This is the Diavola, but it looks similar to the Margherita, which I didn’t have a picture of. Their pizzas are also certified “La Verace Pizza Napoletana,” and it’s the most similar to Da Michele’s.

That said, I’ve had a lot of experience with Pizza Nuova, and while I’ve had a couple of great pizzas there, it can be inconsistent. Often, that restaurant’s pies will get oily and soggy in the middle and turn into a mess.

That wasn’t a problem with Pepe Nero’s somewhat thicker crust. That pie had more and thicker cheese, but that also resulted in some of it not being melted all the way through and pulling off in strips with some bites.

While I wouldn’t compare the pizzas from Pepe Nero or Pizza Nuova to good sex, both are really good.

Declaring a favorite is a tough call, and when I finally do a round up of all the pizzas I’ve tried in Prague, you’ll hear my final answer.

So you could say that these are just tease pizzas. Like a few other things I can think of, you might enjoy my verdict more if you have to wait for it.